Buck Deer 1, Wife and Car 0


car deer smash

From longtime BIG DEER blogger Cory S.:

Hey Mike! Wanted to pass along a pic of what happened a few hours ago. My wife and I were driving with my daughter when a doe suddenly crossed in front of us. Apparently she was “hot” because a couple of seconds later a massive 10 pointer exploded out of the woods and took the car out! The buck bounced off, got up, looked at us like we were crazy and then got back the chase for the doe! Incredible animals I tell ya!

We are all ok. Olivia was a mess and crying though, she thought she had hit and killed the deer. My daughter and I told her the buck was fine and ran off. Her car does smells of rutting buck, though, lol. Tell everyone to be on the lookout for traveling bucks, it’s that time!

Good luck to all this season, and be safe.–Cory

New Science: Whitetail Buck Home Ranges

VA 2014 jack great cam

For his graduate research project at Auburn, deer researcher Clint McCoy tracked the movements of 37 GPS-collared bucks on a 6,400-acre hunting site with excellent habitat in South Carolina. Read the full story at QDMA.com; here are a few highlights with my observations:

Clint found average fall home range size for a buck was 350 acres. A buck’s age did not seem to play a role in how far he moved. “Our two smallest home ranges were yearling bucks at 60 and 90 acres. Our two largest home ranges of 754 and 640 acres were also yearling bucks.”

This seems to contradict some earlier studies which found that older bucks have the smallest home ranges of all bucks. But this finding in Clint’s study might be an anomaly. To me, it’s quite possible that the yearling bucks he tracked for 600-700 acres were going through the “drifter stage,” when juvenile bucks travel far and wide in search of a comfortable place they will call home for the rest of their lives. Several earlier deer studies have suggested young deer do that.

Clint found that more than age, a buck’s individual personality drives his movements. Some bucks tend to cover large acreage while others are content to stay closer to a home base. Clint points to two 4½-year-old bucks in his study: one had a home range of 521 acres, and the other only 108 acres.

This is a finding that confirms something I have been writing about for years—and something that many hunters fail to understand. Like people, all big bucks have different personalities. Some are bold and aggressive, and these are the ones that travel the farthest and show up the most times on trail cams. Other deer are more passive and secretive; they probably travel the least and are seen infrequently.

The more you understand the personality of the buck you are hunting, the more you can get in his head and try to predict how much and when he’ll move…and the better chance you’ll get him.

To me, the determining factor here is the high-quality habitat of the South Carolina study area, which is actively managed for wildlife and timber production. Some 300 acres of food plots are planted on the property each year. On an area like this, bucks don’t need to move far to find food, cover and does in the rut, hence the average home range size of only 300 acres.

If you did a similar study on 6,000 acres of wild, rough habitat with little or no agriculture or food plots, the home range size of all bucks would likely be larger, but probably still under 800 acres, as other studies have found.

Breaking: New Wisconsin Record Bow Buck?

WI state record 2014

Thanks to Eric for alerting us to this monster kill:

Mike: Here is the deer I was telling you about. It was scored at a place they refer to as the Dump, a bar that has a big buck contest.  I work with a guy who is an official scorer for Pope and Young who helps this bar score deer. He didn’t score it, but he knows the guy that did. I was told the G-2s were around 7 inches and the 3s and 4s look to be 10 plus. I was also told that the mass measurements were between 45 and 50 inches total. 

I understand the first gross score to be 202 5/8 typical. I am hoping to contact the hunter and get more info on this giant. If anybody knows more, tell us.

PA Bow Buck

pa bow buck big daddy

Mike: A little while back in a blog you had a picture of a buck that
scored in the 120s and asking if the average hunter would kill him. Well here is my answer to that question.

He’s a basic 8 with a couple stickers. Here in Pa. I do not pass on a buck of this size with either bow or rifle and it doesn’t matter if it is early archery season or the last day of rifle season. The fact is that here in Pa., as well as most public land anywhere in the USA, he is a shooter to 95% of the deer hunters I know.

He is not my largest buck by a long shot but I killed him while
hunting with my son and two longtime friends from our camp. We had back straps for dinner followed by Crown Royal next to the fireplace last night and slept in this morning.–Terry “Big Daddy” Murphy

Thanks Big Daddy and way to go.

Who else would have shot this buck…or would you have passed?




rut report

To monitor the upcoming rut in your area and to keep tabs on what your fellow hunters are seeing and shooting, go to the BIG DEER Rut Report, click on your region and join the conversation. Be sure to post pictures of any big rubs or scrapes or other interesting stuff you find in the woods, and for sure post pictures of the deer you shoot. Good luck!

For now while you’re here, tell me what’s going on in your woods. Are they starting to rub and scrape heavy yet? What are you seeing? Is the deer movement good? Are you hunting this weekend?